Clark v Adams: How QOCS Protection Can Be Lost for Abuse of Process

Qualified one-way costs shifting (QOCS) generally protects a claimant in a personal injury claim from enforcement of an adverse costs order beyond the damages and interest awarded, but the protection is not absolute. The Higher Court proceedings in Clark & Ors v Adams & Anore, which ended in March 2026 when the claimants discontinued after the court indicated it would consider abuse of process, show how quickly the position can change. This article focuses solely on the costs issues and does not comment on the underlying allegations.

Key facts

  • Case: Clark & Ors v Adams & Anor [2026] EWHC 62 (KB) (QOCS ruling); no judgment located for the March 2026 trial events
  • Court: High Court, London (Swift J at trial)
  • Costs issue: whether QOCS protection would be lost if the claim were found to be an abuse of process
  • Earlier ruling: in 2024, Soole J accepted that the claim was one for damages for personal injury and therefore attracted QOCS protection, even though only nominal damages were sought.
  • Outcome: the claimants discontinued near the end of the trial

 

What happened in Clark v Adams?

The claim was brough by three claimants and proceeded to a two-week trial in March 2026. In 2024, in Clark v Adams [2024] EWHC 62 (KB), Soole J has accepted that the claim, which sought nominal damages, was one for damages for personal injury and so enjoyed QOCS protection. At this stage, counsel for the defendant stated that abuse of process was not being argued as a basis for removing that protection.

At the final stage of the trial, the court indicated that it wished to consider whether the proceedings amounted to an abuse of process. The claimants’ solicitors said that, as a result, there was no realistic choice but to bring the claim to an end, because their clients had proceeded on the basis that they could not be held liable for the defendants’ costs. The claimants then discontinued. The reports do not indicate that the court ruled on whether QOCS protection would in fact have been lost.

 

How can QOCS protection be lost?

Under CPR Part 44.2, the general rule is that an order for costs against a claimant in a QOCS claim may be enforced only up to the amount of damages and interest the claimant recovers. The main exceptions include:

  • Strike out (CPR 44.15). Where the claim is struck out on the basis that it discloses no reasonable grounds, is an abuse of the court’s process, or is likely to obstruct the just disposal of the proceedings, an order for costs may be enforced without the court’s permission.
  • Fundamental dishonesty and other grounds (CPR 44.16). Further exceptions apply, including where a claim is found to be fundamentally dishonest, and the court’s permission is generally required for enforcement.

The rules are discretionary in application and fact-sensitive. QOCS is best understood as a default protection that can be displaced, not an immunity.

 

Why does the timing of an abuse of process point matter?

The case illustrates three points of practical significance:

  • An earlier ruling on QOCS status may not be the last word. A finding that a claim attracts QOCS protection does not necessarily prevent the court, or a party, from later considering whether an exception applies.
  • Late developments change the costs risk. A claimant who has proceeded on the footing of costs protection may need to reassess quickly if an exception is raised.
  • Discontinuance does not remove the costs question. A discontinuing claimant is usually liable for the defendant’s costs under CPR 38.9 unless the court orders otherwise. How that interacts with the QOCS exceptions was not determined here, so practitioners should treat the point with caution.

 

Practical points for costs practitioners

  • Defendant-side: consider at an early stage whether any QOCS exception may be engaged, and whether the position needs to be expressly reserved. Keep records that support any later costs application
  • Claimant-side: review the costs risk at each stage, including the possibility that an exception is raised late, and ensure that funding and insurance arrangements, including after-the-event cover, take account of it.
  • Both sides: record how QOCS status was determined and by whom, as it affects budgeting, enforcement and the preparation of any later bill of costs.

This article is general information for practitioners and not legal advice.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

What does QOCS stand for?

QOCS stands for qualified one-way shifting. It limits the extent to which a defendant can enforce a costs order against an unsuccessful claimant in a personal injury claim.

Can QOCS protect a claimant who discontinues?

Yes. The Civil Procedure Rules provide exceptions, including where a claim is struck out as an abuse of process or as disclosing no reasonable grounds, and where a claim is found to be fundamentally dishonest.

Does QOCS protect a claimant who discontinues?

The position depends on the circumstances. A Discontinuing claimant is usually liable for the defendant’s costs under CPR 38.6, and whether QOCS limits enforcement will generally depend on whether an exception applies. Specific advice should be taken.

Which claims does QOCS apply to?

QOCS applies mainly to proceedings that include a claim for damages for personal injuries, as well as certain fatal accident and related claims.

 

Speak to Greener Costs about costs risk and QOCS-related assessments

Greener Costs assists solicitors and costs practitioners with costs budgets, bills of costs and detailed assessment. To discuss a matter, call 01204 263047 or email info@greenercosts.co.uk, or use our enquiry form below, and one of our costs professionals will be in touch at the earliest opportunity.

Related reading: Detailed assessment of costs | Costs budgets | Turner v Coupland Cavendish: ATE commissions and SOCA

We're here to support your business

Contacting us is free. It's our goal to put you at ease and offer expert advice on Bill of Costs, Costs Budgets and Costs Drafting

4 Bark Street East, Bolton, BL1 2BQ

01204 263047

info@greenercosts.co.uk

Leave A Message