JBX v Frimley: Can You Recover Most of Your Costs After Losing the Main Issue?

When a claimant succeeds in a clinical negligence claim but loses the principal issue at trial, how should the court approach costs? The answer is not necessarily that the successful party should recover only a reduced proportion of their costs, or that the losing party should automatically receive costs protection.

In JBX v Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust (Costs) [2026] EWHC 2525 (KB), the High Court ordered the Trust to pay 85% of the claimant’s costs on the standard basis, despite the claimant losing the main dispute concerning his future care and accommodation.

The decision provides useful guidance for clinical negligence solicitors and costs lawyers on the application of CPR 44.2; the significance of Part 36 offers and the court’s approach to costs where success is divided between the parties.

 

Background to JBX v Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust

The underlying clinical negligence claim concerned JBX, who suffered a catastrophic hypoxic brain injury following his discharge from Frimley Park Hospital in January 2018. Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust admitted liability, leaving the court to determine disputed aspects of the claimant’s damages.

In JBX v Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust [2026] EWHC 2294 (KB), the High Court considered two principal issues: future care and accommodation, including prolonged care in a specialist neuro rehabilitation unit, and the significant reduction in life expectancy prompting the claimant’s lost years claim.

The claimant argued that his needs would be best met through a domiciliary care arrangement, allowing him to live at home with specialist support. The Trust maintained that residential care was more appropriate given the complexity of his needs.

The court preferred the Trust’s position on future care and accommodation but accepted the claimant’s lost years claim. The damages award totalled £4,341,302.86, together with substantial periodical payments.

Following the damages judgment, the parties disputed the appropriate costs order. The claimant sought his costs on the standard basis, while the Trust argued that its success on the principal issue justified a substantial reduction.

 

Why Did the Court Award 85% of the Claimant’s Costs?

The costs judgment, handed down on 5 October 2026, applied CPR 44.2. This gives the court discretion over whether costs are payable, the amount payable and when payment should be made.

The general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party’s costs. However, the court can make a different order after considering all the circumstances, including the parties’ conduct, their relative success on different issues and any relevant settlement offers.

The judge accepted that JBX was the successful party overall because he had secured a substantial damages award. However, the Trust had won the main dispute about future care and accommodation, which occupied most of the eight-day trial.

The court therefore had to balance the claimant’s overall success against his failure on the principal issue.

It ultimately ordered the Trust to pay 85% of the claimant’s costs on the standard basis, subject to detailed assessment if the amount could not be agreed.

The decision demonstrates that losing an important issue does not automatically prevent a claimant from recovering most of their costs. The court must consider the circumstances of the case as a whole.

 

Does Losing the Main Issue Justify a Reduction in Costs?

Not automatically. The court considered the established approach in Fox v Foundation Piling Ltd and Welsh v Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust, which recognise that a successful party will not necessarily win every issue in litigation.

An issue-based costs order may be appropriate where there is a proper reason to depart from the general rule. However, the mere fact that a party has lost one or more arguments is not, by itself, enough to justify depriving them of part of their costs.

In JBX v Frimley, the future care dispute was significant because it accounted for most of the trial. Nevertheless, the judge also considered whether the claimant had acted reasonably in pursuing his proposed care arrangements and whether the costs could have been avoided.

The claimant’s position was supported by expert evidence, including evidence from medical professionals. The judge did not consider it unreasonable for the claimant to take the domiciliary care option to trial.

This is an important distinction for clinical negligence practitioners. A claimant may lose a substantial issue without having acted unreasonably in pursuing it. The costs consequences should reflect the circumstances, rather than simply the outcome of an individual argument.

 

Why Did the Absence of a Part 36 Offer Matter?

The Trust had made settlement offers in the period leading up to trial, but none was made under CPR Part 36.

Part 36 provides a formal framework for settlement offers with specific costs consequences. Where a defendant wishes to protect its position on costs, a properly constructed and timely offer can be important.

The judge noted that the Trust’s offers were made less than a fortnight before trial, by which time much of the litigation expenditure had already been incurred. The Trust could not simply expect to obtain the advantages associated with Part 36 without making a qualifying offer.

The court also considered the timing of the parties’ positions on future care. The Trust’s opposition to domiciliary care became clear when it served its Counter Schedule and expert evidence on 13 February 2026. By then, considerable expert-related costs had already been incurred.

These factors mattered when assessing whether the claimant could reasonably have avoided the disputed costs.

For defendants, the practical lesson is that late settlement offers may provide limited protection against costs already incurred. For claimant firms, the judgment reinforces the importance of documenting settlement attempts and the development of the parties’ positions throughout the claim.

 

What Does the Decision Mean for Clinical Negligence Costs?

The decision illustrates why costs outcomes cannot always be predicted by looking at which party won the main issue.

When considering a costs order under CPR 44.2, the court may need to examine:

  • Overall success: the damages or other substantive outcome achieved by each party.
  • The issues in dispute: the significance of the issues won and lost, including how much of the trial they occupied.
  • Reasonableness: whether it was reasonable to pursue or contest the relevant arguments.
  • Costs causation: whether particular conduct caused additional expenditure that could reasonably have been avoided.
  • Settlement offers whether offers were made at an appropriate stage and whether Part 36 was used to protect the parties’ positions.

The judgment also shows why criticism of a party’s conduct needs to be connected to the costs consequences. The judge gave limited weight to the parties’ competing criticisms where neither had demonstrated that the alleged conduct had caused meaningful additional costs.

For costs lawyers, this reinforces the importance of identifying the work attributable to particular issues and considering whether there is a sound basis for seeking a percentage reduction or an issue-based order.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a claimant recover costs after losing the main issue at trial?

Yes. Losing a significant issue does not automatically prevent a claimant from recovering most of their costs. In JBX v Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust (Costs) [2026] EWHC 2525 (KB), the claimant recovered 85% of his costs despite losing the principal dispute about future care and accommodation.

What is CPR 44.2?

CPR 44.2 gives the court discretion over costs. Although the general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party’s costs, the court can make a different order after considering all relevant circumstances.

Why are Part 36 offers important in clinical negligence claims?

Part 36 provides a formal settlement procedure with specific costs consequences. A timely and valid offer can help a party protect its position if the dispute proceeds to trial.

What is the significance of the lost years claim in JBX v Frimley?

The claimant succeeded on his lost years claim but lost the main dispute concerning future care and accommodation. The court considered both outcomes when deciding the appropriate costs order.

 

How Can Greener Costs Assist?

Costs disputes following clinical negligence trials can require a detailed assessment of the issues pursued, the work undertaken and the outcome achieved. A party’s success on the main claim does not always settle the question of how much of its costs should be recovered.

Greener Costs assists solicitors and litigators with costs drafting, Points of Dispute, Replies and detailed assessment. We help legal teams scrutinise costs claims and address the issues that can affect recoverability.

Contact Greener Costs to discuss how we can assist with your clinical negligence costs matters.

We're here to support your business

Contacting us is free. It's our goal to put you at ease and offer expert advice on Bill of Costs, Costs Budgets and Costs Drafting

4 Bark Street East, Bolton, BL1 2BQ

01204 263047

info@greenercosts.co.uk

Leave A Message